Sag Harbor's Main Street: A capital fund to counter rising rents
A new nonprofit entity aims to buy commercial properties and provide grants to help independent businesses survive the economic squeeze.
By Claire Darwish ·

Sag Harbor's Main Street faces a paradox: its popularity is driving out the very businesses that created it. On Sunday afternoon, the Sag Harbor Partnership held a public meeting at The Church on Madison Street to outline a financial strategy designed to keep independent shops open in the face of soaring real estate costs. The organization, a nonprofit focused on local quality of life, cited growing concerns about the loss of the district's distinct character as the primary driver for the new initiative.
The core of the proposal is the creation of a separate nonprofit entity that would function similarly to ReMain Nantucket, a Massachusetts organization that invests in downtown real estate to protect community identity. This new body would establish a capital fund to address market trends that have made it difficult for local businesses to meet their financial obligations. The group is exploring a public-private partnership structure that would utilize private donations and apply for grant funding to support local merchants.
Panelist John Alschuler, a former chairman of HR&A Advisors, described the challenge as a reversal of typical downtown revitalization efforts. He noted that Sag Harbor is not suffering from a downturn but from success. The village's unique appeal has attracted large national brands and eager retailers, which has driven up rent prices and squeezed smaller operators. Alschuler argued that while the Sag Harbor Village government works on zoning regulations, such as a formula store exclusion district, these measures are only part of the solution. A financial plan is needed to ensure that cherished businesses can afford to remain.
Fred Thiele, a former New York State Assemblyman and lifelong resident, drew a parallel to the state's farmland preservation program. He explained that in 1975, land was often more valuable for development than for farming. The state addressed this by purchasing development rights, allowing farmers to keep their land while the public preserved open space. Thiele stated that the same logic applies to small businesses. The public benefits from the sense of place and year-round commerce, but businesses must remain economically viable. The proposed capital fund would use tools like facade easements or usage covenants to drive equity back into the sector.
The new entity is also considering the purchase of commercial properties on Main Street. If the organization buys a building, it can set rent at an affordable rate for small tenants. In structures with residential units above the shops, the partnership could create a mix of affordable and market-rate apartments. This approach aims to solve a secondary issue facing local retailers: the difficulty of finding workers who can afford to live in the area. Susan Mead, a land-use attorney and co-president of the Sag Harbor Partnership, said the group is aiming to have the new nonprofit created before the end of the year, though it is not yet determined if it will be an extension of the partnership or a standalone organization.
The panel included April Gornik, co-founder of The Church, and Shawn Sachs, CEO of Sunshine Sachs Morgan and Lylis. The meeting provided a forum for residents and business owners to share input on these economic solutions. Thiele emphasized that the initiative is intended to complement, not compete with, the village government's regulatory efforts. He stated that the partnership's focus is to adapt the Nantucket model to Sag Harbor's specific needs, ensuring that the financial tools available match the local reality of a high-demand, limited-supply business district.






