Housing Sales in NYC Suburbs Outpace National Buyer Shift
Newark and Long Island remain seller markets despite a national trend favoring buyers, with local inventory shortages driving competition.
By Thiago Cruz ·

Housing markets in the New York metropolitan area are diverging from the national trend that favors buyers.
An October 2026 analysis by Yahoo Finance identified only five U.S. markets as seller friendly, yet local data shows specific regions in the NYC metro retaining an advantage for sellers. In Newark, New Jersey, 57.6% of homes sold above their original list price as of June 2026. This figure places Newark at the top of the 50 largest U.S. metros for this metric. Sellers in Nassau County also performed well, receiving an average of 99.8% of their asking prices. Suffolk County sellers fared slightly better, averaging 101% of their original asking price.
The demand in these areas stems from buyers seeking more space and lower costs than what is available in New York City. Robert Dekanski, a real estate professional in New Jersey, noted that Newark homes typically sell for between $200,000 and $500,000. This price range contrasts sharply with many New York City properties that reach into the millions. Commuter towns in Essex and Union counties offer a viable alternative for those wanting proximity to Manhattan without the high cost of urban living.
Economic development projects are further fueling this demand. The Newark Bay-Hudson County Extension project is expected to generate approximately $2.8 billion in economic activity and create more than 25,000 jobs in its first phase. In Monmouth County, New Jersey, Netflix is constructing a $1 billion studio at Fort Monmouth. The company states this project will create about 4,000 construction jobs. Lincroft, a township in Monmouth County, ranked No. 19 among the hottest housing markets in the country in July 2026.
Inventory levels continue to constrain the supply side of the market. Data from OneKey MLS reported in September 2026 showed single-family listings down 1.7% in Nassau County and 2.9% in Suffolk County compared to the previous year. Richard Haggerty, CEO of OneKey MLS, stated that inventory remains the main challenge in the New York metro area. He added that with just over four months of supply, buyers are competing for every listing that becomes available. This scarcity keeps prices elevated even as national markets cool.
The dynamics in Manhattan and Brooklyn differ from the suburbs. A Q4 2025 report from Baruch College found that Manhattan recorded 6.9% annual price appreciation, while Brooklyn saw a 2.6% increase. Homes in Manhattan spent 9.2% fewer days on the market year over year. These figures suggest that while the city markets are more balanced, well-located properties still sell quickly. Buyers in these boroughs prioritize proximity to subway stations and daily amenities.
Sellers in all these markets benefit from strategic pricing. Dekanski advises comparing a property to similar homes sold in the area over the past one to two years. He recommends factoring in local market trends and events that could influence value. Sellers who stage their homes effectively and set realistic asking prices are the most likely to achieve strong outcomes in this competitive environment.
More Business · Bad Service · Report a business · Got a Story?






